LAST UPDATED : 2010-07-31 10:53:17 GMT+7 
 


DOWNLOAD
PDF VERSION


Tangled web

 
Editorial Desk
Philippine Daily Inquirer
Publication Date: 06-01-2010

All eyes are fixed on the ongoing court proceedings to determine the innocence or guilt of the suspects in the Maguindanao massacre. Once again the justice system itself is on trial, and not just the accused. But the Ampatuans and their grisly reign have also indicted other institutions besides the justice system.

The Armed Forces of the Philippines and the Philippine National Police stand indicted because of their complicity in emboldening the Ampatuans to consider themselves above the law. They stand indicted as enablers, and quite possibly, accomplices, in corruption. Aside from larger questions of military and police corruption enfeebling these institutions, depriving the ranks of quality leadership and adequate equipment, leading to warlords being deputised as surrogate commanders, there is the question of the Ampatuans being raised to paramount status among regional warlords. This was done with support from the top brass as well as the connivance of officials, civilian and military, so that the Ampatuans could amass military equipment.

The police has announced that it intends to file charges against a civilian employee and a former police official. These are small fry by any measure, when many other officials, all the way up to Camps Aguinaldo and Crame, and the Cabinet officials with oversight over the two institutions, should be investigated, too, for acts of commission or omission.

Thus President Gloria Arroyo and the ruling party stand indicted on the same grounds, on the simple principle of command responsibility, as the paramount status of the Ampatuans among the warlords of Mindanao overlaps, exactly, with the period in power of the present administration. If warlordism is an entrenched problem, predating the present dispensation, what set the Ampatuans apart was their closeness to, and their being coddled by, the President and her party.

Still, the bureaucracy—local and national—stands indicted, too, for either aiding or abetting the amassing of colossal wealth by the clan, on a scale and with such conspicuous consumption not just in Maguindanao but elsewhere, such as Davao City, as to make it impossible to explain how the family’s fortune could have been made legally. At the heart of all this lies the blurring of the lines between public and private coffers on the part of the Ampatuans; the obviously weak and corruptible system of military and civilian procurements, and of accounting of national, regional, and provincial funds in the various offices occupied by members of the clan.

The first order of business is, indeed, to secure justice for the victims of the massacre, particularly since the public is unconvinced that the government is really intent on pursuing the case and securing the conviction of the indicted Ampatuans. But if government eventually letting most, if not all, of the Ampatuans off the hook is a reprehensible possibility, so is letting them keep their fortune, political clout, and along the way, permitting our indicted national institutions to get away scot-free too.

For if this were to happen, the only lesson of the Maguindanao Massacre is that the Ampatuans crossed a line: they engaged in a massacre too ambitious in scope to allow them to get off without a slap on the wrist. Unchanged would remain the tangled web of official cooperation and corruption that enabled the Ampatuans to exercise impunity—which opens up the possibility of another clan aspiring to replace them.

As it is, the massacre has led to a scrutiny of Moro warlords but not their Christian counterparts. Only the Ampatuans stand in the dock when all similar bandit-politicians should be undergoing scrutiny and the policies and official behavior that aid and abet them should be in the process of being systematically stamped out.

We are hurtling towards a national political exercise in which the government shows no signs of wanting to forego with the electoral convenience afforded by warlords. The only signal the administration is sending out is that all warlords must toe the line, to avoid too much of a public fuss. This is the wrong message because it is a cynical and self-serving one.





-
- VIEWS

SEOULJapan’s break with past
SINGAPOREPhilippines' Aquino sets correct moral tone
MANILAExtra rice
BANGKOKCambodia's day of judgement arrives at last
MANILAIs this it?
SEOULTies with Libya
SINGAPOREThe Internet never forgets
SEOULInvincible spirit
TAIPEIDespite bluster, N. Korea could be about to collapse
SINGAPOREFor Cambodia, overdue justice
HA NOIUS-China rivalry in Asean looms over an expanded EAS
KUALA LUMPURSit down and work things out
BANGKOKEast Asia Summit is the right choice for Asean Plus
SEOULNoose tightening
SINGAPOREWage push a factor in China's pace of reform
SEOULWorking smart
BANGKOKThais have little concept of the collective good
TOKYONudge North Korea on abduction talks
MANILAWhat now, boss?
JAKARTAStrengthening the graft busters
KUALA LUMPURNo where to go but down, especially in Kabul itself



   

ANN is supported by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation.

(c)2002 ASIA NEWS NETWORK
1854 Bangna-Trad Road
Bangna, Bangkok, 10260 Thailand

Telephone Number:: (+66)2-338-3333
Fax Number: (+66) 2-338-3311