LAST UPDATED : 2010-07-31 10:53:17 GMT+7 
 


DOWNLOAD
PDF VERSION


Fury in Manila over slur in BBC comedy

 
Alastair McIndoe
The Straits Times
Publication Date: 08-10-2008

Outraged Philippine officials are demanding an apology from the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) over what they say is a humiliatingly racist portrayal of Filipinos in one of its comedy shows.

An episode of Harry And Paul, starring British comics Harry Enfield and Paul Whitehouse, denigrates Filipinas working as maids abroad, they say.

The sketch, broadcast on September 26 and posted on YouTube, shows Enfield's character trying to get his comatose-looking neighbour, played by Whitehouse, to have sex with his Filipina maid. She gyrates and dances provocatively around Whitehouse, while Enfield, in a 'posh' British accent, urges him to 'mount' her.

Filipinos are not amused.

Congresswoman Risa Hontiveros, a women's rights activist, calls the sketch "racist, humiliating and disgusting".

Senator Loren Legarda said: "Surely, some British broadcasting regulations must have been violated by this sorry excuse for a comedy."

The controversy spilled over into the diplomatic arena yesterday (October 7) when foreign secretary Alberto Romulo reportedly summoned Britain's ambassador in Manila, Peter Beckingham, to discuss the matter. The Philippine Embassy in London has sent a letter to the BBC protesting against "this slur on our domestic workers" in Britain.

Filipina maids working overseas are revered figures back home for the sacrifice they make to support their families and for their contribution to the national economy. Sexual and psychological abuse by employers is not uncommon.

Still, does the heated response mean that Filipinos cannot take a joke - albeit a rather tasteless one - at their expense?

The answer is both 'yes' and 'no'.

Filipinos lampoon themselves mercilessly in the entertainment industry - and jokes about the iconic maid working overseas are certainly not off limits.

The local media, too, is unflinchingly critical - sometimes to the point of self-flagellation - about the social and economic problems facing the country.

But Filipinos, too, can be acutely sensitive to criticism from foreigners about their country's problems.

"I guess it's still got something to do with our colonial experience under the Spanish and Americans, and a certain inferiority complex that comes with it," said local journalist Marites Vitug.

"Filipinos are proud people; we know the country is not doing as well as our neighbours, but we don't like to be judged like this either," she said.

This is not the first time that negative portrayals of Filipinos in the entertainment industry overseas have kicked up a storm in the Philippines. Last year, American television network ABC had to apologise for an episode of Desperate Housewives which questioned the competence of Filipino doctors.





-
- TOP STORY

SEOULUS ready to urge other countries for stronger sanctions on N. Korea
BEIJINGGlobal warming blamed for extreme weather
MANILAPhilippine President inks 'truth commission'
BANGKOKBurmese leader plays his cards right
SEOULKorean actor handed W7m fine for hit-and-run
PESHAWARFloods kill at least 230 in Pakistan
TOKYOMitsui believes Japanese tanker was attacked
SHANGHAIChina to shoot film to boost global image
BANGKOKBlast hits Bangkok early Friday, 1 injured
DHAKABangladesh raises wages to end labour unrest
COLOMBOReconciliation not possible with foreign mediated efforts: LTTE leader
SEOULKorean spies botch government orders
CHANGCHUNFloods wash away chemical-filled barrels into China's river
BANGKOKThailand lobbies to stall Cambodia's temple plan
NEW DELHIDelhi struggles to get ready for Oct Games
BANGKOKDSI seeks indictment of Thaksin on terrorism charges
TOKYOJapan carries out 2 executions, first under DPJ
DHAKABangladesh constitution states military takeover never again
BANGKOKBangkok voted 'world's best' before riots
MANILAMost Filipinos give high rating for automated polls, survey shows
BANGKOKThailand says temple plan 'unacceptable' in dispute with Cambodia



   

ANN is supported by the Konrad Adenauer Foundation.

(c)2002 ASIA NEWS NETWORK
1854 Bangna-Trad Road
Bangna, Bangkok, 10260 Thailand

Telephone Number:: (+66)2-338-3333
Fax Number: (+66) 2-338-3311