» Views

Too much power at the centre

Publication Date : 01-11-2012


There is no doubt that India's central government (centre) has too much power. It has reduced the federal structure to a unitary system.

The states feel redundant in many ways. After the general election, the demand for special status may become irrepressible when the spokespersons will be the indigenous, regional parties.

Whatever happens in the next general election--my bet is early 2013--India will emerge an extremely divided country. The usual assumption that the two main political parties--the Congress and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)--will have cornered between them a majority of seats is very likely to go awry. Both have gone down so much in the public esteem that neither of them may even cross the three-figure mark in the 546-member Lok Sabha, the Lower House of Parliament.

It’s obvious that parties of all religious and ideological stripes will be in the fray this time. The vote is bound to be divided. A party that wins more than 50 seats can become a fulcrum to which others might want to attach themselves. This will mean that quite a few parties will have to gather on one platform to garner 273 seats for a combined majority in the Lok Sabha.

The Congress and the BJP have been mauled by charges of corruption, the BJP because of its president Nitin Gadkari’s allegedly fictitious companies and the Congress because of a series of scams topped with bogus land purchases by Congress president Sonia Gandhi’s son-in-law, Robert Vadra. The worse is the arrogance of the two parties that have shown their contempt for the people demanding independent inquiry into the irregularities.

Allegations of corruption will chase the Congress in its electoral campaigns. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh may not escape the slings when the scams could have been nipped in the bud had his office acted. In fact, its connivance, if not complicity, has been a common feature of the scams.

The reshuffle of the Union Cabinet cannot revive hopes when the general impression is that the Congress has become a den of corruption. Most in the Cabinet are neither clean nor competent. And when a comparatively honest minister, Jaipal Reddy, is removed from the petroleum ministry, it is confirmed that the Congress is helpless before the corporate sector in view of the money it funnels into elections.

In comparison, the BJP is less guilty, simply because it has not been in power for more than eight years. The states ruled by it, particularly Karnataka and Madhya Pradesh, have brought the party a bad name.

Yet, corruption in the BJP-run states may not get so much attention as the government of India’s scams which will become the topic in the next general election.

The slight advantage of the Congress will be outweighed by the BJP’s communalism factor. The party is too parochial and too linked with the RSS (National Patriotic Organisation)--the fountainhead of communal hatred. The way in which the BJP went back to supporting Gadkari once the RSS backed him proves once again that the BJP is fiction and RSS the fact. 

It won’t surprise the electorate if the party projects as its prime ministerial candidate Narendra Modi who planned and executed the ethnic cleansing scheme in Gujarat in 2002.

The Congress still has the advantage of its secular appearance. However, most Muslims have moved away from the party in the states where they have an alternative to the BJP. In straight contests, Muslims will side with the Congress but not at places where there are regional alternatives such as in Uttar Pradesh (UP), Bihar and West Bengal. Civil society, which normally tilts towards the Congress, is disillusioned by the fact that a person of Manmohan Singh’s stature keeps quiet under pressure from Sonia Gandhi. It is looking for a third alternative.

Since the Congress and the BJP have fallen in the people’s eyes, other parties, particularly regional, have risen in their esteem. The Assembly elections, first in West Bengal and then in UP, have shown that the electorate prefers regional parties to those that have dispersed themselves in the entire country.

This tendency is not because the people are becoming parochial but because the all-India parties have failed to present a united picture of India. Hence the next Lok Sabha may see many parties, even the tiny ones, trivialising the scenario. The Jats, the Dalits or the Rajputs and Yadavs may come to articulate their castes and sub-castes. Yet this divisive picture does not mean that the country is coming apart. Diversity is its strength.

Demands for an identity of their own may become still louder. The answer does not lie in suppressing such voices and dubbing them anti-national but in decentralising power. There is no doubt that the centre has too much power. It has reduced the federal structure to a unitary system. The states feel redundant in many ways. Bihar has raised the standard for a special status. More and more states will follow suit.

After the general election, the demand may become irrepressible when the spokespersons will be the indigenous, regional parties.
In fact, the Constitution has been frugal in giving powers to states.

There is need for another look at the Constitution so as to give more subjects to the states. Article 370 accords special status to Jammu and Kashmir. It was meant to be a temporary provision but had to be continued indefinitely. Why should the same dictum not apply to other states?  All of them need special status, a status which will not curb their initiative and which will not reduce them to supplicants before the centre.

The centre should have defence, foreign affairs, communications, currency and planning. Probably, it can have one or two more subjects but after a careful consideration so that it does not become too powerful. It is the leader among the equals. However, decentralisation should be effected all the way, from Delhi to state capitals and from there to districts with power ultimately percolating to villages to enable the people to rule themselves. Regional parties would do well to keep this in mind if they do not want to meet the fate of all-India parties.

Many years ago, a Baluch nationalist leader, Mir Ghous Bux Bezano, told me: “Take a lesson from us. Too much concentration of power at Delhi may one day result in a situation that Pakistan is facing today.”

The writer is a veteran journalist and commentator 


Mobile Apps Newsletters ANN on You Tube