ASIA NEWS NETWORK
WE KNOW ASIA BETTER
Philippines protests China water cannon attack
Publication Date : 26-02-2014
Manila says regional peace is threatened
The Philippines on Tuesday strongly protested China’s water cannon attack on Filipino fishermen in a disputed shoal nearly a month ago, citing how such acts “escalate tensions” and “threaten the peace” in the region.
Lt. Col. Ramon Zagala, spokesman of the Armed Forces of the Philippines, told reporters that while the Chinese action was “alarming,” it did not warrant an immediate military response.
“I don’t think it would be appropriate if we send the Philippine Navy at this time. It will just escalate the situation,” Zagala said. “Rest assured that the Armed Forces will do its mandate when the time comes.”
The Department of Foreign Affairs (DFA) summoned Chinese Chargé d’Affaires Sun Xiangyang and presented a note verbale protesting reported incidents of harassment that Chinese vessels had committed to prevent Filipinos from fishing in Panatag Shoal, also known as Scarborough Shoal and Bajo de Masinloc, in the West Philippine Sea, or South China Sea.
The protest was received by the chargé d’affaires. The new Chinese ambassador-designate, Zhao Jinhua, who arrived on Sunday night, has yet to begin officially his tour of duty.
“Bajo de Masinloc is an integral part of the Philippines and over which the Philippines exercises sovereignty, sovereign rights and jurisdiction. Philippine fishing vessels have been routinely, continuously, and peacefully and sustainably fishing in Bajo de Masinloc,” Assistant Foreign Secretary Raul Hernandez told reporters.
President Aquino said he wanted China to explain why its Coast Guard had fired water cannon at the fishermen.
“We’re not sure at this point in time if we can call it their standard operating procedure because as of yesterday, we had fishermen inside the shoal who (were) not being harassed or intimidated by any entity,” he told reporters during a visit to Cebu City, where he marked the 28th anniversary of the People Power Revolution, away from the site of the historic event on Edsa in Quezon City.
China rejects protest
In a statement, Chinese Embassy spokesman Zhang Hua rejected the Philippine protest.
“We urge the Philippine side to work with the Chinese side to resolve differences through bilateral consultations and negotiations,” he said.
Zhang also reiterated China’s position that it had “indisputable sovereignty” over the South China Sea. “Chinese government vessels are conducting regular patrols within China’s jurisdiction,” he said.
The Philippine protest covers the incident on January 27, where a Chinese Coast Guard vessel allegedly sprayed Philippine vessels with water cannon, and nine other reported incidents of harassment Filipinos had reported against patroling Chinese ships, including occasions when they were barred to seek shelter in the shoal during bad weather, the DFA said.
“The whole thing is under protest: Their being there is under protest, and also their attempts to drive away Filipino fishermen are also under protest. The whole scheme that is being undertaken by the Chinese government in our territory and where we have sovereign rights is under protest. The crux, the core issue is the nine-dash line claim which is excessive, expansive and illegal, according to international law,” Hernandez said.
There are currently no Philippine military or government ships around the shoal, having pulled out at the height of the tense standoff with Chinese vessels in 2012. The territory, located some 220 kilometres off Zambales province, is within the Philippines’ 370-km exclusive economic zone and 650km from the nearest Chinese coast in Hainan.
Hernandez could not say if a redeployment of Philippine vessels was among options being considered to protect Philippine fishermen in the area.
He said the DFA was in consultation with the Philippine Coast Guard and the military on a possible course of action.
He said at least three Chinese fishing vessels would “come and go” in the shoal.
Belated PH report
“The department likewise strongly protests the acts of harassment and the manner by which these were committed by China to forcefully drive away Philippine fishing vessels from Bajo de Masinloc. Finally, the department vehemently protests the acts of China when its law enforcement vessels drove away Philippine fishing vessels seeking shelter in the Philippines’ Bajo de Masinloc during inclement weather,” Hernandez said.
“These actions, [this] incident, surely escalate the tension in the area and this further threatens the peace and security and stability in the region,” he added.
The Philippines filed its latest protest against China after Armed Forces Chief of Staff Gen. Emmanuel Bautista during a news forum on Monday talked about the incident nearly a month ago.
For still unclear reasons, a Chinese Coast Guard vessel (Bow No. 3063) allegedly doused water on two Filipino vessels, FB P8 and FB Kim, as they plied the vicinity of the shoal. The vessels were among 14 small Philippine fishing boats present at the time.
Filipino fish trader Macario Forones said the Chinese used wastewater laden with oil while blowing the horn and yelling “Go away, go away” at his fishermen. One or two other Philippine fishing boats were hit by the wastewater, he said.
“The water smelled of oil and smeared the side of my fishing boat,” Forones told The Associated Press by telephone. “But my fishermen did not really leave the area. We’ve spent so much money to travel there and they basically ignored the Chinese.”
Hernandez said it was the first time Chinese authorities had carried out such a hostile act against Filipino fishermen.
The militant fisherfolk group, Pamalakaya, questioned the timing of Bautista’s announcement of the January 27 incident. In a statement, it said that the military should have made it public on the day the fishermen were harassed, not almost a month later.
Pamalakaya said Bautista’s report was “masterfully directed by the US government in vain attempt to exploit the conflict and advance the agenda of the US to check Beijing’s increasing role in global politics and pursue US global hegemony.”—With reports from Christian V. Esguerra, Nikko Dizon and agencies