ASIA NEWS NETWORK
WE KNOW ASIA BETTER
Chinese citizens file suit against Japanese firms for forced
Publication Date : 27-02-2014
Thirty-seven Chinese citizens filed a lawsuit in a Beijing court on Wednesday demanding Japanese apologies and compensation for forced labour during World War II.
It is the first time that Chinese forced labourers and their relatives have lodged such a class-action case in a Chinese court. Observers said the case will increase pressure on Japan to correct its interpretation of its militarist history.
The forced labourers and their relatives want apologies to be carried in mainstream media in China and Japan, as well as compensation from Mitsubishi Materials and Mitsui Mining and Smelting.
Kang Jian, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, said the lawsuit is aimed at safeguarding the victims' dignity and human rights.
Dozens of wartime compensation suits have been filed by Chinese and South Korean citizens in Japan, but almost all have been rejected by Japanese courts.
In 1998, five Chinese survivors of World War II and relatives of other Chinese nationals filed seven lawsuits in Japan against Nishimatsu Construction, alleging that the company forcibly brought Chinese individuals to Hiroshima prefecture during the war and used them as forced labour to build the Yasuno power plant.
The allegations were dismissed by Hiroshima District Court in 2002.
Two years later, Hiroshima High Court reversed the district court's decision and ordered Nishimatsu to pay damages to the plaintiffs.
However, in 2007 Nishimatsu filed an appeal with the Japanese Supreme Court.
The top court, in the final verdict, recognised that construction of the power plant by the company subjected Chinese victims to work in conditions that caused them mental and physical pain, but still dismissed the plaintiffs' compensation claim.
"The Japanese court's move hurt us. We can't accept such an attitude toward history," 58-year-old Liu Guolian, daughter of a labourer, told China Daily on Wednesday.
Her father Liu Qian was abducted to Japan to work in a mine in Nagasaki in 1944.
Liu Guolian's younger brother Liu Guoyou said: "We are angry and disappointed with Japan's incorrect attitude toward its brutal history. It should learn from Germany, seriously reflect on itself and sincerely apologise, so that victims like my father can rest in peace."
Kang showed reporters an X-ray of Liu Qian's leg, which was chopped off by his Japanese supervisor after he stopped working momentarily.
"Most of these Chinese forced labourers were treated inhumanly in Japan, which violated international humanitarian law as well as Chinese and Japanese domestic laws," Kang said.
Zhang Shijie, 88, a labourer who survived, said he was excited about the lawsuit being filed.
Zhang was abducted to Japan in 1944 to work at a coal mine in Nagasaki.
"We didn't have enough to eat and we were treated like prisoners," he said, adding that he and other workers were often beaten at work by Japanese foremen.
It will take some time before the lawsuit can be put on record officially and the court sessions begin, but lawyers for the plaintiffs, including Kang, are confident they can win.
Mitsubishi Materials was unable to comment because it did not know the details of the latest case, a spokesman for the company told Reuters.
Under Chinese law, Mitsubishi Materials, which has offices in Shanghai, should pay compensation to the plaintiffs if they win, said Zou Qiang-lun, another lawyer in the case.
Japan's Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga said he was aware of reports about the case, adding that it concerns individuals and private companies.
"However, we believe that according to a joint declaration between Japan and China the (right) to make these claims does not exist," he was quoted as saying by Reuters.
The Japanese government insists that all wartime compensation issues concerning China were settled by a 1972 joint statement establishing diplomatic ties.
But the Chinese Foreign Ministry said Japan's unilateral interpretation of the joint statement is "void".
On Wednesday, ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying urged Japan to show a responsible attitude toward its history and handle the case appropriately.
The case comes amid strained relations between the two countries following Japan's illegal "purchase" of China's Diaoyu Islands in September 2012.
Tensions increased after Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe visited the Yasukuni Shrine in December. The Tokyo shrine honours Japanese war dead, including 14 Class-A World War II war criminals.
Kang denied that the lawsuit is related to ties between the two nations.
But Wang Ping, a researcher of Japanese studies at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said, "The case, together with recent similar cases in South Korea, will increase moral pressure on Japan."
Wang Xinsheng, a history and international affairs professor at Peking University, said Japan should correct its concept of history, otherwise it will become more isolated in East Asia.
Nearly 39,000 Chinese labourers were abducted and forced to work for 35 Japanese companies from 1943 to 1945 and nearly 7,000 of them died in Japan. Nearly 9,500 Chinese labourers worked for the two Japanese companies named in the latest lawsuit, and 1,745 of them died.